Fourth Competition · Judging Verdict · 01 Apr – 30 Apr 2026
14 Winners 16 Disqualified
Fourth Competition · Judging Verdict

Verdict Matrix

33 traders evaluated · ranks 1–33 · 14 winners · 0 borderline · 16 disqualified
Every evaluated trader against the three rules. Click any row for that trader's full evidence and equity curve. Trade slice opens that trader's rows from the source export as a colour-shaded workbook — to check the verdict against the data, not against this page. Click a column header to sort. A single combined Numbers workbook with all 34 tabs sits in the project folder alongside this dashboard.
hard rule broken (overlap >5%, martingale, single >$10K) review flag (DCA >0.10% — manual review, not auto-DQ) clear, with headroom
# Trader Overlap cluster
cap 5% of equity
DCA / Martingale Max single trade
cap $10,000
Verdict Source rows
1asmat224461.71%0.178%$9,602DISQUALIFIEDtrade slice ↓
2okere9.67%0.162%$9,860DISQUALIFIEDtrade slice ↓
3Prime4.36%0.034%$7,167WINNERtrade slice ↓
4Ragu12.87%0.023%$6,860DISQUALIFIEDtrade slice ↓
5shann2916.32%0.100%$6,626DISQUALIFIEDtrade slice ↓
6safal7.32%2.039%$9,698DISQUALIFIEDtrade slice ↓
7PANZERARES_052.52%0.094%$5,232WINNERtrade slice ↓
8Aquiles7.04%0.161%$9,064DISQUALIFIEDtrade slice ↓
9studentsguideclub@gmail.com1.47%0.047%$8,312WINNERtrade slice ↓
10hemendrapal55510.98%0.512%$5,955DISQUALIFIEDtrade slice ↓
11JhansonAlexander32.55%0.670%$9,350DISQUALIFIEDtrade slice ↓
12Yoobra3.66%*0.650%*$2,059WINNERtrade slice ↓
13Sharofatbonu15.74%0.104%$1,685DISQUALIFIEDtrade slice ↓
14TomenyThato6.20%0.196%$5,441DISQUALIFIEDtrade slice ↓
15Sniper208.52%0.005%$9,794DISQUALIFIEDtrade slice ↓
16Aro2u5.39%0.173%$6,881DISQUALIFIEDtrade slice ↓
17Faith0.00%0.056%$8,486WINNERtrade slice ↓
18Dileep1235.34%0.109%$5,330DISQUALIFIEDtrade slice ↓
19akashji2.08%$4,604WINNERtrade slice ↓
20Tsilavina.4.71%0.132%*$2,636WINNERtrade slice ↓
21arjun0468534.68%$9,655WINNERtrade slice ↓
22Elghandour5557.13%0.024%$5,592DISQUALIFIEDtrade slice ↓
23ERANKTRADER4.92%$4,347WINNERtrade slice ↓
24Phillyy0.00%$9,835WINNERtrade slice ↓
25Funtrader30.44%0.193%$7,136DISQUALIFIEDtrade slice ↓
26Bishop1.25%$2,253WINNERtrade slice ↓
27lordofmart2.61%0.034%$9,641WINNERtrade slice ↓
28chameseddine9.85%0.013%$5,515DISQUALIFIEDtrade slice ↓
29Ceecelate902.24%0.005%$4,996WINNERtrade slice ↓
30gOhypeR1.16%0.316%$4,332WINNERtrade slice ↓
Rank 3 · SELECTED · Prize $400K Evaluation

Prime

Account 73821 · Login 569755  ·  trade slice (XLSX) ↓
+$50,844
Net P&L
Trades
31
Win Rate
61.3%
Max Drawdown
2.3%
Profit Factor
9.48
Final Equity
$250,844
Selection Basis
Clean — clears the overlap, DCA and martingale rules
  • 31 trades · +$50,844 · 2.3% max drawdown · 61.3% win rate
  • Overlap: largest moment of concurrent exposure = 4.36% of equity, under the 5% cap.
  • DCA: 5 averaging grid(s), worst add at 0.034% adverse — all under the DCA review threshold.
  • Largest single trade +$7,167, under the $10K cap. No martingale.
Equity Curve
Equity Overlap cluster >5% Real DCA add Martingale streak
Rank 7 · SELECTED · Prize $200K Evaluation

PANZERARES_05

Account 73910 · Login 570462  ·  trade slice (XLSX) ↓
+$45,467
Net P&L
Trades
33
Win Rate
75.8%
Max Drawdown
2.4%
Profit Factor
5.26
Final Equity
$245,467
Selection Basis
Clean — clears the overlap, DCA and martingale rules
  • 33 trades · +$45,467 · 2.4% max drawdown · 75.8% win rate
  • Overlap: largest moment of concurrent exposure = 2.52% of equity, under the 5% cap.
  • DCA: 4 averaging grid(s), worst add at 0.094% adverse — all under the DCA review threshold.
  • Largest single trade +$5,232, under the $10K cap. No martingale.
Equity Curve
Equity Overlap cluster >5% Real DCA add Martingale streak
Rank 9 · SELECTED · Prize $100K Evaluation

studentsguideclub@gmail.com

Account 74262 · Login 575970  ·  trade slice (XLSX) ↓
+$22,753
Net P&L
Trades
23
Win Rate
73.9%
Max Drawdown
1.4%
Profit Factor
5.99
Final Equity
$222,753
Selection Basis
Clean — clears the overlap, DCA and martingale rules
  • 23 trades · +$22,753 · 1.4% max drawdown · 73.9% win rate
  • Overlap: largest moment of concurrent exposure = 1.47% of equity, under the 5% cap.
  • DCA: 3 averaging grid(s), worst add at 0.047% adverse — all under the DCA review threshold.
  • Largest single trade +$8,312, under the $10K cap. No martingale.
Equity Curve
Equity Overlap cluster >5% Real DCA add Martingale streak
Rank 17 · SELECTED · Prize $10K Evaluation

Faith

Account 73314 · Login 566812  ·  trade slice (XLSX) ↓
+$20,565
Net P&L
Trades
22
Win Rate
59.1%
Max Drawdown
2.9%
Profit Factor
3.11
Final Equity
$220,565
Selection Basis
Clean — clears the overlap, DCA and martingale rules
  • 22 trades · +$20,565 · 2.9% max drawdown · 59.1% win rate
  • Overlap: largest moment of concurrent exposure = 0.00% of equity, under the 5% cap.
  • DCA: 1 averaging grid(s), worst add at 0.056% adverse — all under the DCA review threshold.
  • Largest single trade +$8,486, under the $10K cap. No martingale.
Equity Curve
Equity Overlap cluster >5% Real DCA add Martingale streak
Rank 19 · SELECTED · Prize $10K Evaluation

akashji

Account 74388 · Login 578184  ·  trade slice (XLSX) ↓
+$8,561
Net P&L
Trades
13
Win Rate
61.5%
Max Drawdown
3.7%
Profit Factor
1.90
Final Equity
$208,561
Selection Basis
Clean — clears the overlap, DCA and martingale rules
  • 13 trades · +$8,561 · 3.7% max drawdown · 61.5% win rate
  • Overlap: largest moment of concurrent exposure = 2.08% of equity, under the 5% cap.
  • DCA: no averaging-down grids at all.
  • Largest single trade +$4,851, under the $10K cap. No martingale.
Equity Curve
Equity Overlap cluster >5% Real DCA add Martingale streak
Rank 20 · SELECTED — JUDGMENT OVERRIDE · Prize $10K Evaluation

Tsilavina.

Account 73503 · Login 567728  ·  trade slice (XLSX) ↓
+$16,500
Net P&L
Trades
386
Win Rate
44.3%
Max Drawdown
12.2%
Profit Factor
1.11
Final Equity
$216,500
Selection Basis — Override
Winner by override — one isolated DCA event, lofixcasm precedent applied
  • 386 trades · +$16,500 · 12.2% max drawdown · 44.3% win rate
  • Overlap: largest moment of concurrent exposure = 4.71% of equity, under the 5% cap.
  • DCA: 69 averaging grid(s), 1 add past the 0.10% review trigger — worst at 0.132% adverse. Override applied per playbook.
  • Largest single trade +$2,636, under the $10K cap. No martingale.
Winner by judgment override. One isolated DCA event across 386 trades: a gold grid where an add landed after a 0.132% adverse move — just past the DCA review threshold. Tsilavina. is a clearer grid-scalper profile (386 trades, one breach) with similar margin to noise. The single breach is documented in the evidence section below for transparency.
Evidence · Trade-Level Detail
REAL DCA GRIDXAUUSD Buy · worst step 0.132% adverse · 1 add(s) past the 0.10% review trigger · -$5,912
7 trades · anchor 4731.08 → worst 4722.02 · window Apr 13 13:59:41 → Apr 13 14:21:46
Trade IDOpenedSideLotsOpen PriceStep Δ adverseCloseNet P&L
ANCHOR1965306Apr 13 13:59:41Buy14731.084721.06-$1,009
hold1965305Apr 13 13:59:42Buy14731.58▲ 0.011%4721.13-$1,052
hold1965307Apr 13 13:59:44Buy14731.88▲ 0.006%4720.81-$1,114
AVG↓1965336Apr 13 14:02:10Buy14725.64▼ 0.132%4718.39-$732
AVG↓1965335Apr 13 14:02:12Buy14725.52▼ 0.003%4716.83-$876
AVG↓1965334Apr 13 14:03:54Buy14722.55▼ 0.063%4716.98-$564
AVG↓1965337Apr 13 14:03:54Buy14722.02▼ 0.011%4716.44-$565
Equity Curve
Equity Overlap cluster >5% Real DCA add Martingale streak
Rank 21 · SELECTED · Prize $10K Evaluation

arjun046853

Account 73393 · Login 567174  ·  trade slice (XLSX) ↓
+$19,574
Net P&L
Trades
29
Win Rate
37.9%
Max Drawdown
6.1%
Profit Factor
1.47
Final Equity
$219,574
Selection Basis
Clean — clears the overlap, DCA and martingale rules
  • 29 trades · +$19,574 · 6.1% max drawdown · 37.9% win rate
  • Overlap: largest moment of concurrent exposure = 4.68% of equity, under the 5% cap.
  • DCA: no averaging-down grids at all.
  • Largest single trade +$9,655, under the $10K cap. No martingale.
Equity Curve
Equity Overlap cluster >5% Real DCA add Martingale streak
Rank 24 · SELECTED · Prize $5K Evaluation

Phillyy

Account 74078 · Login 572442  ·  trade slice (XLSX) ↓
+$14,848
Net P&L
Trades
5
Win Rate
40.0%
Max Drawdown
1.3%
Profit Factor
4.12
Final Equity
$214,848
Selection Basis
Clean — sequential trader, no overlapping positions
  • 5 trades · +$14,848 · 1.3% max drawdown · 40.0% win rate
  • Overlap: no two positions ever open at the same moment — zero concurrent-cluster risk.
  • DCA: no averaging-down grids at all.
  • Largest single trade +$9,835, under the $10K cap. No martingale.
Equity Curve
Equity Overlap cluster >5% Real DCA add Martingale streak
Rank 26 · SELECTED · Prize $5K Evaluation

Bishop

Account 73805 · Login 569689  ·  trade slice (XLSX) ↓
+$10,065
Net P&L
Trades
16
Win Rate
62.5%
Max Drawdown
0.6%
Profit Factor
5.31
Final Equity
$210,065
Selection Basis
Clean — clears the overlap, DCA and martingale rules
  • 16 trades · +$10,065 · 0.6% max drawdown · 62.5% win rate
  • Overlap: largest moment of concurrent exposure = 1.25% of equity, under the 5% cap.
  • DCA: no averaging-down grids at all.
  • Largest single trade +$2,253, under the $10K cap. No martingale.
Equity Curve
Equity Overlap cluster >5% Real DCA add Martingale streak
Rank 27 · SELECTED · Prize $5K Evaluation

lordofmart

Account 73002 · Login 565905  ·  trade slice (XLSX) ↓
+$11,409
Net P&L
Trades
58
Win Rate
70.7%
Max Drawdown
6.0%
Profit Factor
1.30
Final Equity
$211,409
Selection Basis
Clean — clears the overlap, DCA and martingale rules
  • 58 trades · +$11,409 · 6.0% max drawdown · 70.7% win rate
  • Overlap: largest moment of concurrent exposure = 2.61% of equity, under the 5% cap.
  • DCA: 3 averaging grid(s), worst add at 0.034% adverse — all under the DCA review threshold.
  • Largest single trade +$9,641, under the $10K cap. No martingale.
Equity Curve
Equity Overlap cluster >5% Real DCA add Martingale streak
Rank 29 · SELECTED · Prize $5K Evaluation

Ceecelate90

Account 73900 · Login 570335  ·  trade slice (XLSX) ↓
+$8,863
Net P&L
Trades
24
Win Rate
54.2%
Max Drawdown
2.3%
Profit Factor
1.82
Final Equity
$208,863
Selection Basis
Clean — clears the overlap, DCA and martingale rules
  • 24 trades · +$8,863 · 2.3% max drawdown · 54.2% win rate
  • Overlap: largest moment of concurrent exposure = 2.24% of equity, under the 5% cap.
  • DCA: 2 averaging grid(s), worst add at 0.005% adverse — all under the DCA review threshold.
  • Largest single trade +$4,996, under the $10K cap. No martingale.
Equity Curve
Equity Overlap cluster >5% Real DCA add Martingale streak
Rank 18 · DISQUALIFIED

Dileep123

Account 73081 · Login 566205  ·  trade slice (XLSX) ↓
+$22,205
Net P&L
Trades
104
Win Rate
55.8%
Max Drawdown
4.3%
Profit Factor
1.53
Final Equity
$222,205
Disqualification Reason
Overlap cluster 5.34% + 5.00% — strict 5% cap breached
  • 104 trades · +$22,205 · 4.3% max drawdown · 55.8% win rate
  • Overlap cluster 5.34%: 2 BTCUSD trades held concurrently, combined +$10,654 on $199,327 equity. Strict 5% cap breached.
  • Overlap cluster 5.00%: 8 USDJPY trades held concurrently, combined +$10,285 on $205,646 equity. Strict 5% cap breached.
  • Real DCA on XAGUSD Buy: add placed after a 0.109% adverse move — flagged for review (DCA is not auto-DQ).
Evidence · Trade-Level Detail
OVERLAP CLUSTER5.34% of equity · +$10,654 · 2 trades concurrent
Symbols: BTCUSD · start equity $199,327 · window Apr 04 08:44:50 → Apr 06 00:57:55
Trade IDOpenedSymbolSideLotsOpenCloseNet P&L
1952596Apr 04 08:44:50BTCUSDBuy2.7467021.269041+$5,330
1952595Apr 04 08:44:55BTCUSDBuy2.746702069037.5+$5,324
OVERLAP CLUSTER5.00% of equity · +$10,285 · 8 trades concurrent
Symbols: USDJPY · start equity $205,646 · window Apr 10 00:22:22 → Apr 13 01:34:15
Trade IDOpenedSymbolSideLotsOpenCloseNet P&L
1964169Apr 10 00:22:22USDJPYBuy3.7159.206159.762+$1,286
1964166Apr 10 00:22:25USDJPYBuy3.7159.203159.762+$1,293
1964168Apr 10 00:22:27USDJPYBuy3.7159.203159.762+$1,293
1964165Apr 10 00:22:29USDJPYBuy3.7159.206159.762+$1,286
1964170Apr 10 00:22:31USDJPYBuy3.7159.204159.762+$1,291
1964164Apr 10 00:22:33USDJPYBuy3.7159.204159.754+$1,272
1964167Apr 10 00:22:35USDJPYBuy3.7159.207159.762+$1,284
1964163Apr 10 00:22:37USDJPYBuy3.7159.204159.757+$1,279
REAL DCA GRIDXAGUSD Buy · worst step 0.109% adverse · 1 add(s) past the 0.10% review trigger · +$5,814
6 trades · anchor 79.56 → worst 79.546 · window Apr 15 00:50:27 → Apr 16 01:37:02
Trade IDOpenedSideLotsOpen PriceStep Δ adverseCloseNet P&L
ANCHOR1968978Apr 15 00:50:27Buy0.1979.5680.14+$491
AVG↓1968965Apr 15 00:50:30Buy0.1979.546▼ 0.018%80.463+$811
hold1968964Apr 15 13:42:51Buy0.3279.713▲ 0.210%80.442+$1,065
AVG↓1968963Apr 15 13:43:08Buy0.3279.702▼ 0.014%80.446+$1,089
AVG↓1968962Apr 15 13:43:11Buy0.3279.696▼ 0.008%80.447+$1,100
AVG↓1968961Apr 15 13:43:19Buy0.3279.609▼ 0.109%80.459+$1,259
Equity Curve · Violations Highlighted
Equity Overlap cluster >5% Real DCA add Martingale streak
Rank 1 · DISQUALIFIED

asmat2244

Account 73890 · Login 570202  ·  trade slice (XLSX) ↓
+$118,085
Net P&L
Trades
101
Win Rate
70.3%
Max Drawdown
3.8%
Profit Factor
4.25
Final Equity
$318,085
Disqualification Reason
Overlap cluster 61.7%
  • 101 trades · +$118,085 · 3.8% max drawdown · 70.3% win rate
  • Overlap cluster 61.71%: 20 trades on XAUUSD held concurrently, combined +$123,425 on $200,000 equity.
  • Real DCA on XAUUSD Buy: add placed after a 0.178% adverse move — flagged for review (DCA is not auto-DQ).
  • Real DCA on XAUUSD Buy: add placed after a 0.102% adverse move — flagged for review (DCA is not auto-DQ).
Evidence · Trade-Level Detail
OVERLAP CLUSTER61.71% of equity · +$123,425 · 20 trades concurrent
Symbols: XAUUSD · start equity $200,000 · window Apr 07 16:20:04 → Apr 08 00:56:30
Trade IDOpenedSymbolSideLotsOpenCloseNet P&L
1957547Apr 07 16:20:04XAUUSDBuy0.44656.324821.02+$6,537
1957546Apr 07 16:20:04XAUUSDBuy0.44656.324821.45+$6,554
1957548Apr 07 16:20:04XAUUSDBuy0.54656.324820.63+$8,152
1957549Apr 07 16:20:04XAUUSDBuy0.594656.324820.35+$9,602
1957551Apr 07 16:20:04XAUUSDBuy0.24656.264819.76+$3,244
1957552Apr 07 16:20:04XAUUSDBuy0.294656.264818.31+$4,662
1957550Apr 07 16:20:04XAUUSDBuy0.34656.264820.47+$4,888
1957554Apr 07 16:20:04XAUUSDBuy0.334656.264817.91+$5,292
1957555Apr 07 16:20:04XAUUSDBuy0.374656.264818.64+$5,961
1957553Apr 07 16:20:04XAUUSDBuy0.44656.264817.86+$6,413
1957540Apr 07 16:20:05XAUUSDBuy0.54656.054822.68+$8,268
1957541Apr 07 16:20:05XAUUSDBuy0.44656.054823.14+$6,632
1957543Apr 07 16:20:05XAUUSDBuy0.34656.054821.64+$4,929
1957544Apr 07 16:20:05XAUUSDBuy0.44656.054821.34+$6,560
… 6 more trades
REAL DCA GRIDXAUUSD Buy · worst step 0.178% adverse · 1 add(s) past the 0.10% review trigger · -$2,044
2 trades · anchor 4802.04 → worst 4793.5 · window Apr 20 02:18:11 → Apr 20 03:10:11
Trade IDOpenedSideLotsOpen PriceStep Δ adverseCloseNet P&L
ANCHOR1971673Apr 20 02:18:11Buy1.724802.044791.76-$1,780
AVG↓1971672Apr 20 02:56:33Buy1.464793.5▼ 0.178%4791.76-$264
REAL DCA GRIDXAUUSD Buy · worst step 0.102% adverse · 1 add(s) past the 0.10% review trigger · -$3,576
3 trades · anchor 4781.55 → worst 4775.17 · window Apr 17 01:20:39 → Apr 17 01:28:02
Trade IDOpenedSideLotsOpen PriceStep Δ adverseCloseNet P&L
ANCHOR1970051Apr 17 01:20:39Buy1.344781.554770.03-$1,553
AVG↓1970050Apr 17 01:21:33Buy1.344780.04▼ 0.032%4770.06-$1,347
AVG↓1970049Apr 17 01:25:45Buy1.344775.17▼ 0.102%4770.19-$677
Equity Curve · Violations Highlighted
Equity Overlap cluster >5% Real DCA add Martingale streak
Rank 2 · DISQUALIFIED

okere

Account 73506 · Login 567734  ·  trade slice (XLSX) ↓
+$76,814
Net P&L
Trades
107
Win Rate
50.5%
Max Drawdown
4.5%
Profit Factor
3.19
Final Equity
$276,814
Disqualification Reason
Overlap cluster 9.7%
  • 107 trades · +$76,814 · 4.5% max drawdown · 50.5% win rate
  • Overlap cluster 9.67%: 3 trades on GER40, NAS100, SPX500 held concurrently, combined +$22,077 on $228,350 equity.
  • Overlap cluster 9.04%: 3 trades on GER40, NAS100, SPX500 held concurrently, combined +$18,233 on $201,719 equity.
  • Overlap cluster 8.46%: 3 trades on GER40, NAS100, US30 held concurrently, combined +$19,317 on $228,350 equity.
  • + 3 more overlap clusters over 5% — see evidence below.
  • Real DCA on XAUUSD Buy: add placed after a 0.162% adverse move — flagged for review (DCA is not auto-DQ).
  • Real DCA on SPX500 Buy: add placed after a 0.109% adverse move — flagged for review (DCA is not auto-DQ).
  • + 1 more real-DCA grids — see evidence below.
Evidence · Trade-Level Detail
OVERLAP CLUSTER9.67% of equity · +$22,077 · 3 trades concurrent
Symbols: GER40, NAS100, SPX500 · start equity $228,350 · window Apr 13 09:30:28 → Apr 13 19:06:50
Trade IDOpenedSymbolSideLotsOpenCloseNet P&L
1965410Apr 13 09:30:28SPX500Buy206784.26833.5+$9,860
1965892Apr 13 09:30:54GER40Buy2023585.223905.5+$7,531
1965893Apr 13 09:31:26NAS100Buy14.924978.825293.3+$4,686
OVERLAP CLUSTER9.04% of equity · +$18,233 · 3 trades concurrent
Symbols: GER40, NAS100, SPX500 · start equity $201,719 · window Apr 02 14:03:57 → Apr 02 18:39:49
Trade IDOpenedSymbolSideLotsOpenCloseNet P&L
1951089Apr 02 14:03:57SPX500Buy206519.26567.6+$9,680
1951567Apr 02 14:04:06GER40Buy2022862.423167.8+$7,045
1951179Apr 02 14:04:37NAS100Buy6.923716.823935.4+$1,508
OVERLAP CLUSTER8.46% of equity · +$19,317 · 3 trades concurrent
Symbols: GER40, NAS100, US30 · start equity $228,350 · window Apr 13 09:30:54 → Apr 13 19:06:54
Trade IDOpenedSymbolSideLotsOpenCloseNet P&L
1965892Apr 13 09:30:54GER40Buy2023585.223905.5+$7,531
1965893Apr 13 09:31:26NAS100Buy14.924978.825293.3+$4,686
1965894Apr 13 15:44:31US30Buy204770148056+$7,100
OVERLAP CLUSTER8.14% of equity · +$17,235 · 3 trades concurrent
Symbols: GER40, NAS100, SPX500 · start equity $211,792 · window Apr 09 09:02:52 → Apr 10 05:24:36
Trade IDOpenedSymbolSideLotsOpenCloseNet P&L
1961150Apr 09 09:02:52SPX500Buy206757.26805.8+$9,720
1961475Apr 09 09:04:12GER40Buy9.623767.523903+$1,524
1962075Apr 09 14:28:16NAS100Buy202482225126.7+$5,991
OVERLAP CLUSTER6.67% of equity · +$16,531 · 4 trades concurrent
Symbols: NAS100, SPX500, US30 · start equity $247,877 · window Apr 17 08:40:55 → Apr 17 13:29:50
Trade IDOpenedSymbolSideLotsOpenCloseNet P&L
1970604Apr 17 08:40:55SPX500Buy207060.57104.9+$8,880
1970608Apr 17 08:44:44NAS100Buy3.426376.726581.7+$697
1970778Apr 17 10:33:52US30Buy104876849106+$3,380
1970767Apr 17 10:34:08NAS100Buy1826379.426578+$3,574
OVERLAP CLUSTER5.40% of equity · +$11,432 · 3 trades concurrent
Symbols: GER40, NAS100, SPX500 · start equity $211,792 · window Apr 09 09:02:52 → Apr 09 17:30:47
Trade IDOpenedSymbolSideLotsOpenCloseNet P&L
1961150Apr 09 09:02:52SPX500Buy206757.26805.8+$9,720
1960883Apr 09 09:03:14NAS100Buy202481724826.4+$188
1961475Apr 09 09:04:12GER40Buy9.623767.523903+$1,524
REAL DCA GRIDXAUUSD Buy · worst step 0.162% adverse · 1 add(s) past the 0.10% review trigger · -$753
2 trades · anchor 4827.4 → worst 4819.56 · window Apr 15 13:57:10 → Apr 15 14:48:43
Trade IDOpenedSideLotsOpen PriceStep Δ adverseCloseNet P&L
ANCHOR1968570Apr 15 13:57:10Buy0.34827.44815.64-$355
AVG↓1968571Apr 15 14:44:59Buy14819.56▼ 0.162%4815.65-$398
REAL DCA GRIDSPX500 Buy · worst step 0.109% adverse · 1 add(s) past the 0.10% review trigger · +$2,630
3 trades · anchor 7134.1 → worst 7122.6 · window Apr 23 11:52:45 → Apr 23 16:03:26
Trade IDOpenedSideLotsOpen PriceStep Δ adverseCloseNet P&L
ANCHOR1975228Apr 23 11:52:45Buy107134.17142.4+$830
AVG↓1975136Apr 23 12:46:53Buy107126.3▼ 0.109%7126.3+$0
AVG↓1975238Apr 23 12:48:39Buy107122.6▼ 0.052%7140.6+$1,800
REAL DCA GRIDNAS100 Buy · worst step 0.104% adverse · 1 add(s) past the 0.10% review trigger · +$2,346
3 trades · anchor 26566.8 → worst 26533 · window Apr 20 14:42:07 → Apr 21 01:00:14
Trade IDOpenedSideLotsOpen PriceStep Δ adverseCloseNet P&L
ANCHOR1972536Apr 20 14:42:07Buy2026566.826695.8+$2,470
AVG↓1972276Apr 20 14:53:13Buy826539▼ 0.104%26538-$8
AVG↓1972278Apr 20 14:55:27Buy826533▼ 0.023%26518.5-$116
Equity Curve · Violations Highlighted
Equity Overlap cluster >5% Real DCA add Martingale streak
Rank 4 · DISQUALIFIED

Ragu

Account 74153 · Login 573437  ·  trade slice (XLSX) ↓
+$54,264
Net P&L
Trades
96
Win Rate
77.1%
Max Drawdown
5.7%
Profit Factor
2.69
Final Equity
$254,264
Disqualification Reason
Overlap cluster 12.9%
  • 96 trades · +$54,264 · 5.7% max drawdown · 77.1% win rate
  • Overlap cluster 12.87%: 4 trades on XAUUSD held concurrently, combined +$27,418 on $213,078 equity.
  • Overlap cluster 6.56%: 4 trades on XAUUSD held concurrently, combined +$13,112 on $200,000 equity.
  • Overlap cluster 5.71%: 5 trades on XAUUSD held concurrently, combined +$13,504 on $236,640 equity.
Evidence · Trade-Level Detail
OVERLAP CLUSTER12.87% of equity · +$27,418 · 4 trades concurrent
Symbols: XAUUSD · start equity $213,078 · window Apr 21 23:35:53 → Apr 22 07:24:44
Trade IDOpenedSymbolSideLotsOpenCloseNet P&L
1973988Apr 21 23:35:53XAUUSDBuy247314765.37+$6,860
1973987Apr 21 23:35:54XAUUSDBuy24731.014765.36+$6,856
1973986Apr 21 23:35:54XAUUSDBuy24731.014765.38+$6,860
1973985Apr 21 23:35:55XAUUSDBuy24731.074765.35+$6,842
OVERLAP CLUSTER6.56% of equity · +$13,112 · 4 trades concurrent
Symbols: XAUUSD · start equity $200,000 · window Apr 15 02:16:14 → Apr 15 02:33:57
Trade IDOpenedSymbolSideLotsOpenCloseNet P&L
1967788Apr 15 02:16:14XAUUSDSell24844.764828.17+$3,304
1967790Apr 15 02:16:14XAUUSDSell24844.744828.04+$3,326
1967787Apr 15 02:16:15XAUUSDSell24844.744828.28+$3,278
1967789Apr 15 02:16:15XAUUSDSell24844.444828.35+$3,204
OVERLAP CLUSTER5.71% of equity · +$13,504 · 5 trades concurrent
Symbols: XAUUSD · start equity $236,640 · window Apr 28 00:56:30 → Apr 28 01:55:46
Trade IDOpenedSymbolSideLotsOpenCloseNet P&L
1977672Apr 28 00:56:30XAUUSDSell24693.44679.79+$2,708
1977673Apr 28 00:56:32XAUUSDSell24693.44679.72+$2,722
1977674Apr 28 00:56:33XAUUSDSell24693.254679.69+$2,698
1977675Apr 28 00:56:34XAUUSDSell24693.254679.82+$2,672
1977676Apr 28 00:56:38XAUUSDSell24693.194679.6+$2,704
Equity Curve · Violations Highlighted
Equity Overlap cluster >5% Real DCA add Martingale streak
Rank 5 · DISQUALIFIED

shann29

Account 73199 · Login 566503  ·  trade slice (XLSX) ↓
+$55,275
Net P&L
Trades
144
Win Rate
73.6%
Max Drawdown
4.8%
Profit Factor
2.97
Final Equity
$255,275
Disqualification Reason
Overlap cluster 16.3%
  • 144 trades · +$55,275 · 4.8% max drawdown · 73.6% win rate
  • Overlap cluster 16.32%: 9 trades on XAGUSD held concurrently, combined +$32,645 on $200,000 equity.
  • Overlap cluster 9.12%: 6 trades on XAGUSD held concurrently, combined +$21,176 on $232,283 equity.
Evidence · Trade-Level Detail
OVERLAP CLUSTER16.32% of equity · +$32,645 · 9 trades concurrent
Symbols: XAGUSD · start equity $200,000 · window Apr 01 06:57:23 → Apr 01 07:45:51
Trade IDOpenedSymbolSideLotsOpenCloseNet P&L
1944731Apr 01 06:57:23XAGUSDSell275.27374.622+$6,496
1944730Apr 01 06:57:26XAGUSDSell275.26674.636+$6,286
1944729Apr 01 06:57:29XAGUSDSell275.28574.621+$6,626
1944723Apr 01 06:57:31XAGUSDSell275.27874.662+$6,146
1944722Apr 01 06:57:34XAGUSDSell275.30874.668+$6,386
1944596Apr 01 06:57:47XAGUSDSell0.175.31275.076+$117
1944595Apr 01 06:57:52XAGUSDSell0.175.31475.056+$128
1944633Apr 01 06:57:55XAGUSDSell0.175.33374.861+$235
1944632Apr 01 06:57:57XAGUSDSell0.175.30474.854+$224
OVERLAP CLUSTER9.12% of equity · +$21,176 · 6 trades concurrent
Symbols: XAGUSD · start equity $232,283 · window Apr 01 07:51:36 → Apr 01 08:02:44
Trade IDOpenedSymbolSideLotsOpenCloseNet P&L
1944841Apr 01 07:51:36XAGUSDSell274.47474.344+$1,286
1944837Apr 01 07:51:40XAGUSDSell274.47274.312+$1,586
1944797Apr 01 07:51:42XAGUSDSell274.48774.093+$3,926
1944796Apr 01 07:51:44XAGUSDSell274.49274.039+$4,516
1944795Apr 01 07:51:46XAGUSDSell274.574.014+$4,846
1944794Apr 01 07:51:48XAGUSDSell274.48273.979+$5,016
Equity Curve · Violations Highlighted
Equity Overlap cluster >5% Real DCA add Martingale streak
Rank 6 · DISQUALIFIED

safal

Account 72785 · Login 565529  ·  trade slice (XLSX) ↓
+$46,785
Net P&L
Trades
48
Win Rate
58.3%
Max Drawdown
5.0%
Profit Factor
3.05
Final Equity
$246,785
Disqualification Reason
Overlap cluster 7.3%
  • 48 trades · +$46,785 · 5.0% max drawdown · 58.3% win rate
  • Overlap cluster 7.32%: 3 trades on BTCUSD, XAGUSD, XAUUSD held concurrently, combined +$14,642 on $200,000 equity.
  • Overlap cluster 6.89%: 3 trades on XAGUSD held concurrently, combined +$14,799 on $214,642 equity.
  • Real DCA on XAGUSD Sell: add placed after a 2.039% adverse move — flagged for review (DCA is not auto-DQ).
  • Real DCA on XAGUSD Sell: add placed after a 0.958% adverse move — flagged for review (DCA is not auto-DQ).
  • + 3 more real-DCA grids — see evidence below.
Evidence · Trade-Level Detail
OVERLAP CLUSTER7.32% of equity · +$14,642 · 3 trades concurrent
Symbols: BTCUSD, XAGUSD, XAUUSD · start equity $200,000 · window Apr 02 13:15:43 → Apr 06 03:42:06
Trade IDOpenedSymbolSideLotsOpenCloseNet P&L
1952815Apr 02 13:15:43XAUUSDBuy0.54591.694628.83+$1,615
1952813Apr 02 13:18:09XAGUSDBuy169.87271.717+$8,855
1952814Apr 03 06:39:27BTCUSDBuy266784.768981.5+$4,171
OVERLAP CLUSTER6.89% of equity · +$14,799 · 3 trades concurrent
Symbols: XAGUSD · start equity $214,642 · window Apr 06 03:42:32 → Apr 06 11:48:43
Trade IDOpenedSymbolSideLotsOpenCloseNet P&L
1953299Apr 06 03:42:32XAGUSDBuy171.84373.05+$6,028
1953485Apr 06 03:42:32XAGUSDBuy171.84373.25+$7,028
1952917Apr 06 04:32:18XAGUSDBuy172.18272.532+$1,743
REAL DCA GRIDXAGUSD Sell · worst step 2.039% adverse · 1 add(s) past the 0.10% review trigger · +$10,846
3 trades · anchor 78.803 → worst 80.315 · window Apr 14 14:10:40 → Apr 15 10:09:07
Trade IDOpenedSideLotsOpen PriceStep Δ adverseCloseNet P&L
ANCHOR1968234Apr 14 14:10:40Sell0.578.80378.682+$306
hold1968203Apr 14 14:12:51Sell0.578.71▲ 0.118%78.375+$841
AVG↓1968202Apr 15 02:40:48Sell180.315▼ 2.039%78.374+$9,698
REAL DCA GRIDXAGUSD Sell · worst step 0.958% adverse · 1 add(s) past the 0.10% review trigger · -$6,234
3 trades · anchor 77.218 → worst 77.963 · window Apr 14 12:23:43 → Apr 14 14:09:36
Trade IDOpenedSideLotsOpen PriceStep Δ adverseCloseNet P&L
ANCHOR1967065Apr 14 12:23:43Sell0.477.21878.767-$3,101
AVG↓1967064Apr 14 12:24:08Sell0.477.223▼ 0.006%78.78-$3,117
AVG↓1967007Apr 14 13:26:11Sell0.577.963▼ 0.958%77.968-$16
REAL DCA GRIDXAGUSD Sell · worst step 0.523% adverse · 1 add(s) past the 0.10% review trigger · +$3,812
3 trades · anchor 71.883 → worst 72.259 · window Apr 07 17:11:20 → Apr 07 18:58:17
Trade IDOpenedSideLotsOpen PriceStep Δ adverseCloseNet P&L
ANCHOR1956885Apr 07 17:11:20Sell0.371.88371.369+$769
hold1956894Apr 07 17:11:20Sell0.771.883▲ 0.000%71.351+$1,857
AVG↓1956865Apr 07 17:38:13Sell0.572.259▼ 0.523%71.783+$1,186
REAL DCA GRIDXAUUSD Sell · worst step 0.351% adverse · 1 add(s) past the 0.10% review trigger · +$1,501
3 trades · anchor 4666.17 → worst 4682.55 · window Apr 07 17:11:28 → Apr 07 18:57:16
Trade IDOpenedSideLotsOpen PriceStep Δ adverseCloseNet P&L
ANCHOR1956882Apr 07 17:11:28Sell0.54666.174660.27+$292
hold1956893Apr 07 17:11:28Sell0.54666.17▲ 0.000%4658.8+$365
AVG↓1956881Apr 07 17:38:49Sell0.54682.55▼ 0.351%4665.59+$844
REAL DCA GRIDXAUUSD Buy · worst step 0.278% adverse · 1 add(s) past the 0.10% review trigger · -$1,095
2 trades · anchor 4651.99 → worst 4639.07 · window Apr 06 19:13:38 → Apr 07 02:55:00
Trade IDOpenedSideLotsOpen PriceStep Δ adverseCloseNet P&L
ANCHOR1954731Apr 06 19:13:38Buy24651.994650.27-$599
AVG↓1954713Apr 07 02:35:12Buy24639.07▼ 0.278%4636.66-$496
Equity Curve · Violations Highlighted
Equity Overlap cluster >5% Real DCA add Martingale streak
Rank 8 · DISQUALIFIED

Aquiles

Account 73769 · Login 569435  ·  trade slice (XLSX) ↓
+$35,561
Net P&L
Trades
18
Win Rate
55.6%
Max Drawdown
4.4%
Profit Factor
2.85
Final Equity
$235,561
Disqualification Reason
Overlap cluster 7.0%
  • 18 trades · +$35,561 · 4.4% max drawdown · 55.6% win rate
  • Overlap cluster 7.04%: 2 trades on AUDUSD held concurrently, combined +$15,497 on $220,064 equity.
  • Real DCA on AUDUSD Buy: add placed after a 0.161% adverse move — flagged for review (DCA is not auto-DQ).
Evidence · Trade-Level Detail
OVERLAP CLUSTER7.04% of equity · +$15,497 · 2 trades concurrent
Symbols: AUDUSD · start equity $220,064 · window Apr 24 17:01:16 → Apr 27 09:50:49
Trade IDOpenedSymbolSideLotsOpenCloseNet P&L
1976781Apr 24 17:01:16AUDUSDBuy220.715340.71837+$6,433
1976780Apr 26 22:04:29AUDUSDBuy220.714190.71838+$9,064
REAL DCA GRIDAUDUSD Buy · worst step 0.161% adverse · 1 add(s) past the 0.10% review trigger · +$15,497
2 trades · anchor 0.71534 → worst 0.71419 · window Apr 24 17:01:16 → Apr 27 09:50:49
Trade IDOpenedSideLotsOpen PriceStep Δ adverseCloseNet P&L
ANCHOR1976781Apr 24 17:01:16Buy220.715340.71837+$6,433
AVG↓1976780Apr 26 22:04:29Buy220.71419▼ 0.161%0.71838+$9,064
Equity Curve · Violations Highlighted
Equity Overlap cluster >5% Real DCA add Martingale streak
Rank 10 · DISQUALIFIED

hemendrapal555

Account 73142 · Login 566368  ·  trade slice (XLSX) ↓
+$36,717
Net P&L
Trades
100
Win Rate
64.0%
Max Drawdown
3.0%
Profit Factor
2.52
Final Equity
$236,717
Disqualification Reason
Overlap cluster 11.0%
  • 100 trades · +$36,717 · 3.0% max drawdown · 64.0% win rate
  • Overlap cluster 10.98%: 8 trades on XAUUSD held concurrently, combined +$22,705 on $206,822 equity.
  • Real DCA on XAUUSD Buy: add placed after a 0.512% adverse move — flagged for review (DCA is not auto-DQ).
  • Real DCA on XAUUSD Buy: add placed after a 0.436% adverse move — flagged for review (DCA is not auto-DQ).
  • + 1 more real-DCA grids — see evidence below.
Evidence · Trade-Level Detail
OVERLAP CLUSTER10.98% of equity · +$22,705 · 8 trades concurrent
Symbols: XAUUSD · start equity $206,822 · window Apr 09 06:01:13 → Apr 09 12:41:49
Trade IDOpenedSymbolSideLotsOpenCloseNet P&L
1960518Apr 09 06:01:13XAUUSDBuy24717.44745.15+$5,536
1960519Apr 09 06:01:17XAUUSDBuy24717.064745.14+$5,602
1960520Apr 09 06:01:37XAUUSDBuy24718.24744+$5,146
1960521Apr 09 06:01:39XAUUSDBuy24718.324745.13+$5,348
1960522Apr 09 06:02:04XAUUSDBuy0.14718.874746.73+$278
1960523Apr 09 06:02:10XAUUSDBuy0.14719.024745.97+$269
1960524Apr 09 06:02:27XAUUSDBuy0.14718.824746.08+$272
1960525Apr 09 06:02:33XAUUSDBuy0.14719.244744.73+$254
REAL DCA GRIDXAUUSD Buy · worst step 0.512% adverse · 1 add(s) past the 0.10% review trigger · +$959
2 trades · anchor 4673.07 → worst 4649.14 · window Apr 06 05:23:54 → Apr 06 08:00:12
Trade IDOpenedSideLotsOpen PriceStep Δ adverseCloseNet P&L
ANCHOR1953146Apr 06 05:23:54Buy14673.074682.4+$926
AVG↓1953147Apr 06 07:23:04Buy0.014649.14▼ 0.512%4682.62+$33
REAL DCA GRIDXAUUSD Buy · worst step 0.436% adverse · 1 add(s) past the 0.10% review trigger · -$780
2 trades · anchor 4653.08 → worst 4632.79 · window Apr 07 14:49:24 → Apr 07 15:21:28
Trade IDOpenedSideLotsOpen PriceStep Δ adverseCloseNet P&L
ANCHOR1956497Apr 07 14:49:24Buy2.54653.084649.64-$878
AVG↓1956473Apr 07 15:03:15Buy0.14632.79▼ 0.436%4642.57+$97
REAL DCA GRIDXAUUSD Buy · worst step 0.104% adverse · 1 add(s) past the 0.10% review trigger · +$337
2 trades · anchor 4879.81 → worst 4874.73 · window Apr 17 14:26:50 → Apr 17 14:41:35
Trade IDOpenedSideLotsOpen PriceStep Δ adverseCloseNet P&L
ANCHOR1970913Apr 17 14:26:50Buy0.14879.814880.31+$4
AVG↓1970901Apr 17 14:32:14Buy2.54874.73▼ 0.104%4876.13+$332
Equity Curve · Violations Highlighted
Equity Overlap cluster >5% Real DCA add Martingale streak
Rank 11 · DISQUALIFIED

JhansonAlexander

Account 74212 · Login 574379  ·  trade slice (XLSX) ↓
+$34,012
Net P&L
Trades
80
Win Rate
58.8%
Max Drawdown
15.9%
Profit Factor
1.55
Final Equity
$234,012
Disqualification Reason
Overlap cluster 32.5%
  • 80 trades · +$34,012 · 15.9% max drawdown · 58.8% win rate
  • Overlap cluster 32.55%: 35 trades on XAUUSD held concurrently, combined +$63,957 on $196,493 equity.
  • Overlap cluster 9.68%: 5 trades on XAUUSD held concurrently, combined +$24,576 on $253,792 equity.
  • Real DCA on ETHUSD Buy: add placed after a 0.670% adverse move — flagged for review (DCA is not auto-DQ).
Evidence · Trade-Level Detail
OVERLAP CLUSTER32.55% of equity · +$63,957 · 35 trades concurrent
Symbols: XAUUSD · start equity $196,493 · window Apr 17 07:44:12 → Apr 17 17:18:14
Trade IDOpenedSymbolSideLotsOpenCloseNet P&L
1971088Apr 17 07:44:12XAUUSDBuy0.84785.644863.37+$6,213
1971062Apr 17 07:44:12XAUUSDBuy0.14785.644863.21+$775
1971063Apr 17 07:44:12XAUUSDBuy0.14785.644862.78+$771
1971064Apr 17 07:44:12XAUUSDBuy0.14785.644862.87+$772
1971065Apr 17 07:44:12XAUUSDBuy0.14785.644862.56+$768
1971066Apr 17 07:44:12XAUUSDBuy0.14785.644862.43+$767
1971074Apr 17 07:44:12XAUUSDBuy0.34785.644864+$2,349
1971067Apr 17 07:44:12XAUUSDBuy0.14785.644862.44+$767
1971068Apr 17 07:44:12XAUUSDBuy0.14785.644862.48+$768
1971069Apr 17 07:44:12XAUUSDBuy0.24785.644863.53+$1,556
1971071Apr 17 07:44:12XAUUSDBuy0.24785.644864.79+$1,582
1971072Apr 17 07:44:12XAUUSDBuy0.24785.644864.18+$1,569
1971073Apr 17 07:44:12XAUUSDBuy0.24785.644864.02+$1,566
1971070Apr 17 07:44:12XAUUSDBuy0.24785.644864.55+$1,577
… 21 more trades
OVERLAP CLUSTER9.68% of equity · +$24,576 · 5 trades concurrent
Symbols: XAUUSD · start equity $253,792 · window Apr 19 23:55:50 → Apr 20 14:36:47
Trade IDOpenedSymbolSideLotsOpenCloseNet P&L
1972230Apr 19 23:55:50XAUUSDBuy14752.614814.66+$6,198
1972229Apr 19 23:57:16XAUUSDBuy1.54752.084814.48+$9,350
1972228Apr 20 05:47:09XAUUSDBuy14784.044814.82+$3,071
1972227Apr 20 05:51:41XAUUSDBuy147854814.8+$2,973
1972226Apr 20 05:51:47XAUUSDBuy14785.014814.93+$2,985
REAL DCA GRIDETHUSD Buy · worst step 0.670% adverse · 1 add(s) past the 0.10% review trigger · -$6,656
7 trades · anchor 2338.82 → worst 2322.73 · window Apr 19 05:36:44 → Apr 19 07:25:57
Trade IDOpenedSideLotsOpen PriceStep Δ adverseCloseNet P&L
ANCHOR1971449Apr 19 05:36:44Buy302338.822301.65-$1,115
hold1971447Apr 19 05:36:45Buy302338.82▲ 0.000%2300.26-$1,157
AVG↓1971452Apr 19 05:36:47Buy302338.65▼ 0.007%2302.04-$1,098
AVG↓1971451Apr 19 05:36:48Buy302338.65▲ 0.000%2301.84-$1,104
hold1971450Apr 19 05:36:49Buy302338.82▲ 0.007%2301.8-$1,111
AVG↓1971448Apr 19 07:11:07Buy302323.16▼ 0.670%2301.65-$645
AVG↓1971445Apr 19 07:11:12Buy302322.73▼ 0.019%2308.54-$426
Equity Curve · Violations Highlighted
Equity Overlap cluster >5% Real DCA add Martingale streak
Rank 12 · WINNER (override) · Prize $50K Evaluation

Yoobra

Account 74164 · Login 573557  ·  trade slice (XLSX) ↓
+$29,407
Net P&L
Trades
147
Win Rate
63.9%
Max Drawdown
1.7%
Profit Factor
3.13
Final Equity
$229,407
Winner — Override
No rule broken on April-only data
  • 147 trades · +$29,407 · 1.7% max drawdown · 63.9% win rate · 3.13 PF
  • Overlap clusters (27.25%, 9.03%): both occurred in May — outside the 01 Apr – 30 Apr competition window. Excluded from evaluation.
  • April-only max concurrent exposure: 3.66% of equity (17 XAUUSD trades, Apr 30 12:13). Below the 5% cap — no breach.
  • Algorithmic "Real DCA" flags on BTCUSD Sell (0.65% step) and BTCUSD Buy (0.21% step): the lot pattern is mixed scalping/grid, not classic DCA structure. Each grid trips the 0.10% review trigger on one or two scalp adds. Judgment call: not real DCA.
  • No martingale, no max-single-trade breach on the April-only book.
Equity Curve · Violations Highlighted
Equity Overlap cluster >5% Real DCA add Martingale streak
Rank 13 · DISQUALIFIED

Sharofatbonu

Account 74401 · Login 578987  ·  trade slice (XLSX) ↓
+$30,103
Net P&L
Trades
317
Win Rate
20.8%
Max Drawdown
0.9%
Profit Factor
14.81
Final Equity
$230,103
Disqualification Reason
Overlap cluster 15.7%
  • 317 trades · +$30,103 · 0.9% max drawdown · 20.8% win rate
  • Overlap cluster 15.74%: 21 trades on XAUUSD held concurrently, combined +$31,483 on $200,000 equity.
  • Overlap cluster 10.17%: 14 trades on XAUUSD held concurrently, combined +$20,349 on $200,000 equity.
  • Real DCA on XAUUSD Buy: add placed after a 0.104% adverse move — flagged for review (DCA is not auto-DQ).
Evidence · Trade-Level Detail
OVERLAP CLUSTER15.74% of equity · +$31,483 · 21 trades concurrent
Symbols: XAUUSD · start equity $200,000 · window Apr 29 19:57:02 → Apr 30 20:15:26
Trade IDOpenedSymbolSideLotsOpenCloseNet P&L
1979402Apr 29 19:57:02XAUUSDBuy0.224548.564616.44+$1,414
1979418Apr 29 19:57:55XAUUSDBuy0.224546.184616.26+$1,462
1979410Apr 29 19:58:16XAUUSDBuy0.224544.84616.4+$1,496
1979411Apr 29 19:59:00XAUUSDBuy0.224544.594616.27+$1,498
1979420Apr 29 20:16:46XAUUSDBuy0.224543.514616.26+$1,521
1979409Apr 29 20:17:24XAUUSDBuy0.224542.774616.4+$1,541
1979412Apr 29 20:48:42XAUUSDBuy0.224543.14616.26+$1,530
1979419Apr 29 20:49:58XAUUSDBuy0.224542.184616.26+$1,550
1979403Apr 29 22:04:12XAUUSDBuy0.224541.34616.44+$1,652
1979421Apr 29 22:04:12XAUUSDBuy0.224540.394616.26+$1,668
1979404Apr 29 22:04:12XAUUSDBuy0.224540.124616.44+$1,678
1979408Apr 29 22:04:49XAUUSDBuy0.224539.734616.4+$1,685
1979110Apr 29 23:31:16XAUUSDBuy0.224552.154597.65+$999
1979417Apr 30 04:03:23XAUUSDBuy0.224551.644616.26+$1,420
… 7 more trades
OVERLAP CLUSTER10.17% of equity · +$20,349 · 14 trades concurrent
Symbols: XAUUSD · start equity $200,000 · window Apr 29 19:57:02 → Apr 30 20:15:26
Trade IDOpenedSymbolSideLotsOpenCloseNet P&L
1979402Apr 29 19:57:02XAUUSDBuy0.224548.564616.44+$1,414
1979020Apr 29 19:57:45XAUUSDBuy0.224547.384580.79+$656
1979418Apr 29 19:57:55XAUUSDBuy0.224546.184616.26+$1,462
1979410Apr 29 19:58:16XAUUSDBuy0.224544.84616.4+$1,496
1979411Apr 29 19:59:00XAUUSDBuy0.224544.594616.27+$1,498
1979420Apr 29 20:16:46XAUUSDBuy0.224543.514616.26+$1,521
1979409Apr 29 20:17:24XAUUSDBuy0.224542.774616.4+$1,541
1979412Apr 29 20:48:42XAUUSDBuy0.224543.14616.26+$1,530
1979419Apr 29 20:49:58XAUUSDBuy0.224542.184616.26+$1,550
1979403Apr 29 22:04:12XAUUSDBuy0.224541.34616.44+$1,652
1979421Apr 29 22:04:12XAUUSDBuy0.224540.394616.26+$1,668
1979404Apr 29 22:04:12XAUUSDBuy0.224540.124616.44+$1,678
1979408Apr 29 22:04:49XAUUSDBuy0.224539.734616.4+$1,685
1979110Apr 29 23:31:16XAUUSDBuy0.224552.154597.65+$999
REAL DCA GRIDXAUUSD Buy · worst step 0.104% adverse · 1 add(s) past the 0.10% review trigger · +$32,139
22 trades · anchor 4548.56 → worst 4539.73 · window Apr 29 19:57:02 → Apr 30 20:15:26
Trade IDOpenedSideLotsOpen PriceStep Δ adverseCloseNet P&L
ANCHOR1979402Apr 29 19:57:02Buy0.224548.564616.44+$1,414
AVG↓1979020Apr 29 19:57:45Buy0.224547.38▼ 0.026%4580.79+$656
AVG↓1979418Apr 29 19:57:55Buy0.224546.18▼ 0.026%4616.26+$1,462
AVG↓1979410Apr 29 19:58:16Buy0.224544.8▼ 0.030%4616.4+$1,496
AVG↓1979411Apr 29 19:59:00Buy0.224544.59▼ 0.005%4616.27+$1,498
AVG↓1979420Apr 29 20:16:46Buy0.224543.51▼ 0.024%4616.26+$1,521
AVG↓1979409Apr 29 20:17:24Buy0.224542.77▼ 0.016%4616.4+$1,541
AVG↓1979412Apr 29 20:48:42Buy0.224543.1▲ 0.007%4616.26+$1,530
AVG↓1979419Apr 29 20:49:58Buy0.224542.18▼ 0.020%4616.26+$1,550
AVG↓1979403Apr 29 22:04:12Buy0.224541.3▼ 0.019%4616.44+$1,652
AVG↓1979421Apr 29 22:04:12Buy0.224540.39▼ 0.020%4616.26+$1,668
AVG↓1979404Apr 29 22:04:12Buy0.224540.12▼ 0.006%4616.44+$1,678
AVG↓1979408Apr 29 22:04:49Buy0.224539.73▼ 0.009%4616.4+$1,685
hold1979110Apr 29 23:31:16Buy0.224552.15▲ 0.274%4597.65+$999
AVG↓1979417Apr 30 04:03:23Buy0.224551.64▼ 0.011%4616.26+$1,420
AVG↓1979416Apr 30 04:03:39Buy0.224551.29▼ 0.008%4616.26+$1,428
… 6 more trades
Equity Curve · Violations Highlighted
Equity Overlap cluster >5% Real DCA add Martingale streak
Rank 14 · DISQUALIFIED

TomenyThato

Account 73852 · Login 569934  ·  trade slice (XLSX) ↓
+$20,937
Net P&L
Trades
29
Win Rate
62.1%
Max Drawdown
1.8%
Profit Factor
3.17
Final Equity
$220,937
Disqualification Reason
Overlap cluster 6.2%
  • 29 trades · +$20,937 · 1.8% max drawdown · 62.1% win rate
  • Overlap cluster 6.20%: 4 trades on EURGBP, SPX500, USDCAD, XAGUSD held concurrently, combined +$12,655 on $204,187 equity.
  • Overlap cluster 6.18%: 4 trades on EURGBP, SPX500, USDCAD, XAUUSD held concurrently, combined +$12,612 on $204,187 equity.
  • Real DCA on USDCAD Sell: add placed after a 0.196% adverse move — flagged for review (DCA is not auto-DQ).
Evidence · Trade-Level Detail
OVERLAP CLUSTER6.20% of equity · +$12,655 · 4 trades concurrent
Symbols: EURGBP, SPX500, USDCAD, XAGUSD · start equity $204,187 · window Apr 13 13:20:48 → Apr 14 16:04:52
Trade IDOpenedSymbolSideLotsOpenCloseNet P&L
1967309Apr 13 13:20:48EURGBPSell40.870360.86941+$500
1966429Apr 13 13:21:48XAGUSDBuy0.2574.10277.774+$4,564
1967310Apr 13 13:22:37SPX500Buy3.36796.26962.5+$5,441
1967311Apr 13 13:23:10USDCADSell41.383411.37584+$2,149
OVERLAP CLUSTER6.18% of equity · +$12,612 · 4 trades concurrent
Symbols: EURGBP, SPX500, USDCAD, XAUUSD · start equity $204,187 · window Apr 13 13:20:48 → Apr 15 01:16:14
Trade IDOpenedSymbolSideLotsOpenCloseNet P&L
1967309Apr 13 13:20:48EURGBPSell40.870360.86941+$500
1967310Apr 13 13:22:37SPX500Buy3.36796.26962.5+$5,441
1967311Apr 13 13:23:10USDCADSell41.383411.37584+$2,149
1967694Apr 14 16:03:59XAUUSDBuy14811.334857.86+$4,521
REAL DCA GRIDUSDCAD Sell · worst step 0.196% adverse · 1 add(s) past the 0.10% review trigger · -$552
2 trades · anchor 1.38152 → worst 1.38423 · window Apr 09 14:24:16 → Apr 13 13:19:38
Trade IDOpenedSideLotsOpen PriceStep Δ adverseCloseNet P&L
ANCHOR1965183Apr 09 14:24:16Sell41.381521.38356-$712
AVG↓1965181Apr 13 10:40:21Sell41.38423▼ 0.196%1.38358+$160
Equity Curve · Violations Highlighted
Equity Overlap cluster >5% Real DCA add Martingale streak
Rank 15 · DISQUALIFIED

Sniper20

Account 73169 · Login 566431  ·  trade slice (XLSX) ↓
+$22,320
Net P&L
Trades
18
Win Rate
50.0%
Max Drawdown
3.0%
Profit Factor
2.49
Final Equity
$222,320
Disqualification Reason
Overlap cluster 8.5%
  • 18 trades · +$22,320 · 3.0% max drawdown · 50.0% win rate
  • Overlap cluster 8.52%: 3 trades on CADJPY, GBPNZD, XAUUSD held concurrently, combined +$16,695 on $196,047 equity.
  • Overlap cluster 8.29%: 6 trades on CADJPY, GBPNZD, XAUUSD held concurrently, combined +$16,252 on $196,047 equity.
  • Overlap cluster 6.17%: 3 trades on CADJPY, GBPNZD, XAUUSD held concurrently, combined +$12,097 on $196,047 equity.
Evidence · Trade-Level Detail
OVERLAP CLUSTER8.52% of equity · +$16,695 · 3 trades concurrent
Symbols: CADJPY, GBPNZD, XAUUSD · start equity $196,047 · window Apr 09 19:26:04 → Apr 17 15:21:26
Trade IDOpenedSymbolSideLotsOpenCloseNet P&L
1970825Apr 09 19:26:04CADJPYBuy10115.172115.747+$3,595
1970954Apr 13 16:45:33GBPNZDSell102.301282.29499+$3,306
1970667Apr 17 11:50:29XAUUSDBuy24807.074856.11+$9,794
OVERLAP CLUSTER8.29% of equity · +$16,252 · 6 trades concurrent
Symbols: CADJPY, GBPNZD, XAUUSD · start equity $196,047 · window Apr 09 19:26:04 → Apr 17 15:21:26
Trade IDOpenedSymbolSideLotsOpenCloseNet P&L
1970825Apr 09 19:26:04CADJPYBuy10115.172115.747+$3,595
1970954Apr 13 16:45:33GBPNZDSell102.301282.29499+$3,306
1969596Apr 15 05:10:46CADJPYBuy10115.431116.076+$3,990
1969916Apr 16 06:35:29XAUUSDSell24817.424792.66+$4,938
1969314Apr 16 09:39:30XAUUSDSell0.014812.054813.63-$2
1970149Apr 16 09:40:00XAUUSDSell0.34812.274798.23+$424
OVERLAP CLUSTER6.17% of equity · +$12,097 · 3 trades concurrent
Symbols: CADJPY, GBPNZD, XAUUSD · start equity $196,047 · window Apr 09 19:26:04 → Apr 17 15:21:26
Trade IDOpenedSymbolSideLotsOpenCloseNet P&L
1970825Apr 09 19:26:04CADJPYBuy10115.172115.747+$3,595
1970954Apr 13 16:45:33GBPNZDSell102.301282.29499+$3,306
1967359Apr 14 07:09:42XAUUSDBuy34793.594810.98+$5,196
Equity Curve · Violations Highlighted
Equity Overlap cluster >5% Real DCA add Martingale streak
Rank 16 · DISQUALIFIED

Aro2u

Account 73947 · Login 570698  ·  trade slice (XLSX) ↓
+$21,913
Net P&L
Trades
50
Win Rate
34.0%
Max Drawdown
4.5%
Profit Factor
1.99
Final Equity
$221,913
Disqualification Reason
Overlap cluster 5.4%
  • 50 trades · +$21,913 · 4.5% max drawdown · 34.0% win rate
  • Overlap cluster 5.39%: 4 trades on BTCUSD, XAUUSD held concurrently, combined +$10,644 on $197,406 equity.
  • Real DCA on GER40 Sell: add placed after a 0.173% adverse move — flagged for review (DCA is not auto-DQ).
Evidence · Trade-Level Detail
OVERLAP CLUSTER5.39% of equity · +$10,644 · 4 trades concurrent
Symbols: BTCUSD, XAUUSD · start equity $197,406 · window Apr 28 09:21:17 → Apr 28 16:50:18
Trade IDOpenedSymbolSideLotsOpenCloseNet P&L
1978294Apr 28 09:21:17XAUUSDSell1.54618.424575.76+$6,388
1978295Apr 28 09:21:17XAUUSDSell0.54618.424576.94+$2,070
1978328Apr 28 09:21:17XAUUSDSell0.484618.424589.59+$1,380
1978265Apr 28 09:31:33BTCUSDSell0.8876674.775760.1+$805
REAL DCA GRIDGER40 Sell · worst step 0.173% adverse · 1 add(s) past the 0.10% review trigger · +$6,945
3 trades · anchor 24043.5 → worst 24085.1 · window Apr 29 06:56:40 → Apr 29 08:43:31
Trade IDOpenedSideLotsOpen PriceStep Δ adverseCloseNet P&L
ANCHOR1978530Apr 29 06:56:40Sell22.924043.523931.3+$3,006
AVG↓1978531Apr 29 07:05:53Sell14.224085.1▼ 0.173%23929.9+$2,578
AVG↓1978529Apr 29 07:24:56Sell9.224056.3▲ 0.120%23929.8+$1,361
Equity Curve · Violations Highlighted
Equity Overlap cluster >5% Real DCA add Martingale streak
Rank 22 · DISQUALIFIED

Elghandour555

Account 73363 · Login 567032  ·  trade slice (XLSX) ↓
+$17,354
Net P&L
Trades
40
Win Rate
22.5%
Max Drawdown
3.4%
Profit Factor
1.97
Final Equity
$217,354
Disqualification Reason
Overlap cluster 7.1%
  • 40 trades · +$17,354 · 3.4% max drawdown · 22.5% win rate
  • Overlap cluster 7.13%: 4 trades on XAUUSD held concurrently, combined +$14,300 on $200,462 equity.
Evidence · Trade-Level Detail
OVERLAP CLUSTER7.13% of equity · +$14,300 · 4 trades concurrent
Symbols: XAUUSD · start equity $200,462 · window Apr 09 00:39:57 → Apr 09 11:40:18
Trade IDOpenedSymbolSideLotsOpenCloseNet P&L
1960296Apr 09 00:39:57XAUUSDBuy14714.24749.82+$3,555
1960295Apr 09 00:39:58XAUUSDBuy14714.134749.95+$3,575
1960297Apr 09 00:39:59XAUUSDBuy14713.614749.82+$3,614
1960294Apr 09 00:40:02XAUUSDBuy14714.494750.12+$3,556
Equity Curve · Violations Highlighted
Equity Overlap cluster >5% Real DCA add Martingale streak
Rank 23 · SELECTED · Prize $10K Evaluation

ERANKTRADER

Account 72872 · Login 565659  ·  trade slice (XLSX) ↓
+$17,853
Net P&L
Trades
65
Win Rate
35.4%
Max Drawdown
7.3%
Profit Factor
1.63
Final Equity
$217,853
Selection Basis
Clean — clears the overlap, DCA and martingale rules
  • 65 trades · +$17,853 · 7.3% max drawdown · 35.4% win rate · 1.63 PF
  • Overlap: largest moment of concurrent exposure = 4.92% of equity, under the 5% cap.
  • DCA: no violations. Multiple XAUUSD adds on Apr 27: price moved above the anchor between entries (4714.89 → 4715.23), breaking any averaging-down chain. Not systematic DCA.
  • Largest single trade +$4,347, under the $10K cap. No martingale.
Equity Curve
Equity Overlap cluster >5% Real DCA add Martingale streak
Rank 25 · DISQUALIFIED

Funtrader

Account 74248 · Login 575664  ·  trade slice (XLSX) ↓
+$14,759
Net P&L
Trades
102
Win Rate
40.2%
Max Drawdown
22.5%
Profit Factor
1.20
Final Equity
$214,759
Disqualification Reason
Overlap cluster 30.4%
  • 102 trades · +$14,759 · 22.5% max drawdown · 40.2% win rate
  • Overlap cluster 30.44%: 15 trades on XAUUSD held concurrently, combined +$64,686 on $212,507 equity.
  • Overlap cluster 7.47%: 4 trades on XAUUSD held concurrently, combined +$14,776 on $197,731 equity.
  • Real DCA on XAUUSD Buy: add placed after a 0.193% adverse move — flagged for review (DCA is not auto-DQ).
Evidence · Trade-Level Detail
OVERLAP CLUSTER30.44% of equity · +$64,686 · 15 trades concurrent
Symbols: XAUUSD · start equity $212,507 · window Apr 19 23:48:26 → Apr 20 14:35:57
Trade IDOpenedSymbolSideLotsOpenCloseNet P&L
1972212Apr 19 23:48:26XAUUSDBuy0.84743.694817+$5,859
1972213Apr 19 23:48:26XAUUSDBuy0.84743.694816.78+$5,842
1972211Apr 19 23:48:26XAUUSDBuy0.84743.694818.03+$5,942
1972214Apr 19 23:48:26XAUUSDBuy0.64743.694816.05+$4,337
1972207Apr 19 23:48:26XAUUSDBuy0.14743.694818.5+$747
1972206Apr 19 23:48:26XAUUSDBuy0.14743.694818.29+$745
1972208Apr 19 23:48:26XAUUSDBuy0.84743.694818.88+$6,010
1972220Apr 19 23:48:26XAUUSDBuy0.84743.724815.5+$5,737
1972215Apr 19 23:48:26XAUUSDBuy0.44743.724815.35+$2,862
1972216Apr 19 23:48:26XAUUSDBuy0.44743.724815.21+$2,857
1972217Apr 19 23:48:26XAUUSDBuy0.84743.724815.46+$5,734
1972218Apr 19 23:48:26XAUUSDBuy0.84743.724814.37+$5,646
1972219Apr 19 23:48:26XAUUSDBuy0.84743.724815.66+$5,750
1972221Apr 19 23:48:32XAUUSDBuy0.934745.154814.91+$6,481
… 1 more trades
OVERLAP CLUSTER7.47% of equity · +$14,776 · 4 trades concurrent
Symbols: XAUUSD · start equity $197,731 · window Apr 19 23:40:21 → Apr 19 23:48:16
Trade IDOpenedSymbolSideLotsOpenCloseNet P&L
1971599Apr 19 23:40:21XAUUSDSell44761.344743.43+$7,136
1971600Apr 19 23:40:22XAUUSDSell44761.164743.3+$7,116
1971598Apr 19 23:40:28XAUUSDSell0.294760.924743.39+$506
1971601Apr 19 23:40:31XAUUSDSell0.014760.454742.95+$17
REAL DCA GRIDXAUUSD Buy · worst step 0.193% adverse · 1 add(s) past the 0.10% review trigger · -$6,808
2 trades · anchor 4829.03 → worst 4819.72 · window Apr 21 00:10:32 → Apr 21 01:40:41
Trade IDOpenedSideLotsOpen PriceStep Δ adverseCloseNet P&L
ANCHOR1972548Apr 21 00:10:32Buy2.54829.034809.78-$4,830
AVG↓1972547Apr 21 00:31:23Buy24819.72▼ 0.193%4809.9-$1,978
Equity Curve · Violations Highlighted
Equity Overlap cluster >5% Real DCA add Martingale streak
Rank 28 · DISQUALIFIED

chameseddine

Account 73455 · Login 567515  ·  trade slice (XLSX) ↓
+$16,715
Net P&L
Trades
16
Win Rate
43.8%
Max Drawdown
2.9%
Profit Factor
2.96
Final Equity
$216,715
Disqualification Reason
Overlap cluster 9.9%
  • 16 trades · +$16,715 · 2.9% max drawdown · 43.8% win rate
  • Overlap cluster 9.85%: 4 trades on EURUSD, GBPUSD held concurrently, combined +$19,707 on $200,000 equity.
Evidence · Trade-Level Detail
OVERLAP CLUSTER9.85% of equity · +$19,707 · 4 trades concurrent
Symbols: EURUSD, GBPUSD · start equity $200,000 · window Apr 02 04:18:45 → Apr 07 23:18:25
Trade IDOpenedSymbolSideLotsOpenCloseNet P&L
1957201Apr 02 04:18:45EURUSDBuy51.153711.16398+$4,886
1957202Apr 02 04:18:45EURUSDBuy51.153731.16393+$4,850
1957390Apr 06 06:14:33GBPUSDBuy31.321891.3386+$4,981
1957389Apr 06 06:14:35GBPUSDBuy31.321891.33863+$4,990
Equity Curve · Violations Highlighted
Equity Overlap cluster >5% Real DCA add Martingale streak
Rank 30 · WINNER (override) · Prize $5K Evaluation

gOhypeR

Account 73134 · Login 566355  ·  trade slice (XLSX) ↓
+$11,300
Net P&L
Trades
138
Win Rate
50.0%
Max Drawdown
2.1%
Profit Factor
1.97
Final Equity
$211,300
Winner — Override
Not real DCA — three sub-0.4% scalp trips on WTI Apr 02
  • 138 trades · +$11,300 · 2.1% max drawdown · 50.0% win rate
  • Overlap clusters: none above the 5% cap. Max cluster 1.16%.
  • "Real DCA" flags on WTI Buy at 0.316% / 0.167% / 0.154% — all three grids opened in 4 hours on Apr 02 with 3–6 trade adds. Per the policy: DCA >0.10% triggers manual review, not auto-DQ. Reviewed: scalp pattern, not classic DCA.
  • No martingale. No single-trade breach.
Equity Curve · Violations Highlighted
Equity Overlap cluster >5% Real DCA add Martingale streak